Wet Vs. Dry Brine For Thanksgiving Turkey? [Which Is Better?]

Thanksgiving is a lovely time of year when families gather, eat a feast, and share what they are thankful for. The turkey is the main attraction in this meal, so ensuring it comes out perfect is the top priority. But should you dry or wet brine the turkey for it to be perfect? 

Dry and wet brining your Thanksgiving turkey are great methods to prepare your turkey. However, the one you should choose depends on your cooking method. If you are smoking the turkey, then use a wet brine. If you are oven baking it, you can use either brining method. 

wet vs. dry brine for Thanksgiving turkey

What are the benefits and cons of wet and dry brining your Thanksgiving turkey? What are wet and dry brining? We will go through all there is to know about wet and dry brining a Thanksgiving turkey in this article!

Dry Brining Vs. Wet Brining Thanksgiving Turkeys

Turkeys are a staple at any Thanksgiving table. It wouldn’t be Thanksgiving without a perfectly cooked, juicy, delicious turkey sitting on the table, ready to be carved and enjoyed. 

For many people, the turkey is the best part of the Thanksgiving feast, so if you are in charge of making it, it can come with a lot of pressure to get it right as you don’t want to ruin anyone’s day. 

This can make cooking the turkey to perfection a challenging task and one that you want to get right. So, when you are cooking your Thanksgiving turkey, should you use wet or dry brine to prepare it? 

Before we find out the best brine for a Thanksgiving turkey, we must go through what wet and dry brining is, so let’s find out. 

What Is Dry Brining?

Dry brining is an easy way to flavor your turkey before cooking it. It is when you thoroughly defrost the turkey and then dry it with a paper towel. Once the turkey is dry to the touch, you will spread a dry rub spice mixture over the entire turkey. 

The dry rub mixture generally consists of your favorite spices, with lots of salt and a sprinkling of sugar to add a slight sweetness to the turkey. You can make your own dry rub spice mix if you have specific spices you wish to use, or you can purchase a ready-made dry rub spice mix from a store. 

You must ensure you cover the entire turkey with the dry rub spice mixture, or your turkey won’t be evenly flavored. Then, the turkey is put in the fridge for at least 4 hours to allow the dry rub to soak into the turkey. 

What Is Wet Brining?

Wet brining is a relatively easy way to ensure your Thanksgiving turkey is well flavored and stays moist throughout the cooking process. The process involves mixing spices, sugar, and salt in water. 

Generally, this mixture is heated on low until the spices, sugar, and salt have dissolved in the water to create a lovely brine, but you can add many other ingredients to help flavor the turkey. Finally, the mixture is left to cool, and the turkey is fully submerged in the brine. 

The turkey is left in the refrigerated brine for 2-3 days to allow the brine to seep into the flesh. This will give the turkey a salty yet somewhat sweet flavor and guarantee that the meat is juicy when cooked.

Pros And Cons Of Wet And Dry Brining Turkeys

Now that you know how wet and dry brines work, you might wonder what the pros and cons of both methods are. These are important to consider when deciding which method will be the best for your Thanksgiving turkey. 

So, let’s go through all the pros and cons of wet and dry brining a turkey to ensure your Thanksgiving turkey comes out perfectly juicy and delicious! 

Pros And Cons Of Dry Brining  

Dry brining a turkey is an easy method to season your Thanksgiving turkey. It generally doesn’t take long, and getting the entire turkey covered with the dry rub is relatively easy. 

If you make your dry rub, you can ensure your Thanksgiving turkey is flavored precisely how you and your family like the turkey flavored. This will ensure that everyone loves the turkey you make. 

You can also purchase dry rubs from local butchers that are ready to use, making it even easier to flavor your turkey. In addition, you only need to dry brine your turkey a few hours before cooking it, so you don’t need to prepare it days in advance.  

There are a few cons when using a dry rub on your turkey. One con is that your turkey can come out dry and crumbly if you aren’t careful, as the dry brine doesn’t add any moisture to the meat. It’s also easy to overseason the turkey with a dry rub, as many people don’t know when to stop adding dry rub. 

Pros And Cons Of Wet Brining

Wet brining a turkey for Thanksgiving is a relatively straightforward process that shouldn’t take long to prepare. You can make the wet brine to suit your tastes, or you can buy a wet brine from your local butcher, which is usually very tasty. 

You can add different ingredients to wet brins, like lemon rinds, to add extra flavor to the turkey. Wet brines ensure your turkey is juicy and flavorful when cooked; it’s rare to have a wet-brined turkey come out dry. 

There are some cons to wet bringing a turkey. One con is that it takes 2 to 3 days to wet brine a turkey, so you need to start the process days before you cook it. Finding a container big enough to brine the turkey in can also be challenging, as they are large birds. 

Wet brining requires you to leave the turkey in your fridge for days, which can take up a large sum of space in your fridge. This can be challenging when planning a feast where other foods must also be refrigerated. 

Which Method Is Best?

The best method for brining a turkey for Thanksgiving depends on a few factors. These aspects include how much time you have to prepare the turkey, available fridge space, and how you are cooking the turkey. 

If you want to ensure your turkey is moist and flavorful, and you have extra space in your fridge and lots of time to prepare the turkey, then wet brining is the best option. 

However, if you don’t have the time, and have no space in the fridge, then the dry method is the best option.

If you are smoking your Thanksgiving turkey, you should consider wet bringing it as it will produce the best results. If you cook the turkey in an oven, you can dry or wet brine, and the turkey should come out perfect. 

Final Word

Brining a turkey is essential to ensure the turkey is seasoned well and juicy after cooking. Both wet and dry brining are good options for preparing your Thanksgiving turkey, but they have pros and drawbacks that you should consider before deciding which method to use. 

Wet brining and dry brining have their place in the kitchen, and the one you choose to use will only depend on the way you’re cooking the turkey.

Good luck making your Thanksgiving turkey!

Related Articles



Skip to content