Brining Vs Injecting A Brisket [What’s The Difference?]

While brisket may be a firm family favorite dish, the process of cooking brisket for long periods makes it prone to drying out. Therefore, people often brine or inject a brisket before cooking, but what are the differences between these methods.

Brining involves submerging a brisket in a salty solution for over 24 hours. This helps the brisket maintain its moisture while cooking. Injecting a brisket involves injecting a fatty or brine mixture into the brisket; this is a faster hydration method.

While both these methods of moisturizing, tenderizing, and adding flavor to brisket are effective, both have their pros and cons. Let’s explore some of them below:

How To Brine A Brisket?

Prior to looking at the advantages and disadvantages of brining brisket, we first need to look at how to brine a brisket:

Find a waterproof container that’s big enough to hold the entire brisket. Allow enough space in the container to fully submerge the brisket in the brine solution.
Boil the amount of water needed while taking note of the number of cups of water used. The ratio of water to kosher salt you will need is one cup of kosher salt for every two cups of water.
Add the correct ratio of kosher salt as the water is boiling, along with peppercorns, thyme, rosemary, and any other spices you may want to include.
Stir the mixture until the salt is thoroughly dissolved. Remove the mixture from the heat source allow it to cool slightly before refrigerating the brine until it is completely chilled.
Once chilled, include any other liquids in the brine (such as lemon juice) before submerging the brisket fully in the brine solution. To keep the brisket submerged, you may need to use a weight, such as a heavy plate.
Place the container with the brine and brisket into the refrigerator. Allow the brisket to sit in the solution for approximately one hour per pound of meat.
Remove the brisket from the brining solution. If any salt is visible on the brisket, run it under cold water and pat it dry with paper towels.
Smoke the brisket and avoid adding any further salt via any spice rubs, sauces, or marinades you may use.

Alternatively, some people opt to dry brine brisket since this is easier and requires less space to perform:

Make sure to have a significant amount of kosher salt (½ teaspoon of salt per pound of meat) and a clean workspace.
Dry the brisket with paper cloths and rub the salt all over the brisket and into all its crevices.
Place the brisket onto a wire rack inside a baking sheet. This catches any juices from the brisket and keeps them away from its surface.
Refrigerate the brisket for a minimum of two hours, although it is recommended that it be left in the fried overnight.

What Are The Advantages Of Brining Brisket?

There are many advantages to brining a brisket before you cook it:

Brining seasons and moistures briskets uniformly,
Brining helps tenderize brisket,
There is room for customization when brining brisket.

What Are The Disadvantages Of Brining Brisket?

There are some disadvantages to brining a brisket:

Lots of salt and salt drippings,
Possible to over salt the brisket, especially depending on any rubs, sauces, or marinades you may be using.
Takes up a lot of space, because you have to use a container to hold the brine.
Brining is a slow process that usually takes up to 24 hours.
Brining can reduce the crispiness of brisket during the cooking process.

How To Inject A Brisket?

As above, we first need to look at how to inject a brisket before we discuss the advantages and disadvantages of injecting brisket:

Prepare and trim your brisket and place it in a deep pan or tray,
Mix your injection liquid (either homemade or store-bought) in a mixing bowl, measuring out one ounce of injection liquid for every pound of brisket.
Fill the syringe by pulling back on the plunger, just make sure that all the holes along the side of the needle are submerged to avoid spraying when filling the syringe.
Choose the direction of injection. While some people recommend injecting brisket with the grain, others say that isn’t necessary as it won’t affect the taste or texture. The most important thing is to make ensure the brisket is evenly injected.
When injecting brisket, it is advisable that you cover the top of the needle to catch any spray (spray is inevitable, meaning injecting brisket can be a messy process).
To evenly inject brisket, utilize a grid pattern for injection, allowing gaps between one and two inches.
Once fully injected, collect and dispose of any remaining injection liquid in the pan.
Lightly pat the brisket with paper towels to absorb any moisture and excess injection liquid before refrigeration or cooking.

What Are The Advantages Of Injecting Brisket?

There are many advantages to injecting a brisket before you cook it:

Injecting brisket is much faster than brining brisket.
Fats and flavors are deposited directly within the meat, as opposed to just the surface of the meat. This helps add flavor and tenderizer to the deepest sections of the brisket.
Injecting helps to keep the outside of the brisket crispy during the cooking process.
Whether store-bought or homemade, injection liquid can include various ingredients to complement the flavor profile, you wish to achieve with your brisket.
Injecting takes up less space than brining a brisket.

What Are The Disadvantages Of Injecting Brisket?

There are some disadvantages to injecting a brisket before you cook it:

Injection can’t have any solid in its mixture, which limits what ingredients can be used in injection liquid. Some of which are used in brining to great effect.
Needles and syringes can get clogged, making the process of injection difficult.
Spray back can make injection a messy process.
Penetration can be uneven if not done correctly.

Final Word

As can be seen above, whether you choose to brine or inject a brisket is dependent on which process you find more convenient and which can complement your brisket’s flavor profiles to your liking.

Both methods when done correctly will infuse great flavor into the meat.

Related Articles

Sources

https://www.napoleon.com/en/us/grills/blog/brining-vs-injecting-which-better